Public Dispositions

Once the JCC determines that a judge has committed judicial misconduct and should be publicly sanctioned for that misconduct, the JCC recommends that the judge be reprimanded, censured, suspended, removed from office or involuntarily retired. Only the Utah Supreme Court can actually impose a reprimand, censure, suspension, removal or involuntary retirement. Prior to the implementation of any JCC recommendation, the Utah Supreme Court reviews the JCC’s proceedings as to both law and fact. The Utah Supreme Court may then issue an order implementing, rejecting or modifying the JCC’s recommendation.

Below, in chronological and then alphabetical order by judges' last names, are the public dispositions issued since January 1, 1997. Click on the disposition to the right of the judge's name to retrieve documents associated with the disposition.

Future public dispositions will be added as they occur. As resources permit, the JCC will add any pre-1997 sanctions. For public dispositions not yet included in the list below, please contact the JCC by telephone at (801) 468-0021.

In cases where the JCC found that the judge's conduct constituted troubling but relatively minor misbehavior for which no public sanction was warranted, the Utah Supreme Court has authorized the JCC to issue a "Dismissal with warning." A Dismissal with warning is published without identifying the judge or the court. At the bottom of this page, is a link to published Dismissals with warning.

JudgeDispositionDate
Sessions, BrookeReprimand07/06/2023
Ridge, StevanCensure07/03/2023
Ridge, StevanCensure07/03/2023
Dow, JohnReprimand09/23/2019
Kwan, MichaelSuspension05/22/2019
Keisel, BrodyReprimand12/28/2018
Kwan, MichaelReprimand11/04/2016
Andrus, J. MarkReprimand04/22/2014
Ward, VirginiaCensure10/11/2013
Christensen, KevinCensure05/21/2013
Johnson, GaryReprimand03/26/2013
Stoney, KeithDismissal09/28/2012
Stoney, KeithRetirement09/11/2012
Peters, RobertReprimand08/22/2012
Hare, RonaldCensure04/06/2011
Adams, KennethReprimand12/20/2010
Ridge, StevanReprimand05/12/2010
Sampson, GarryReprimand12/17/2009
Serassio, DarlaReprimand04/16/2008
Lewis, LeslieCensure08/31/2007
Cox, PaulCensure06/13/2007
Lewis, LeslieReprimand04/26/2007
Halliday, BruceReprimand06/01/2006
Steed, WalterRemoval02/24/2006
Kwan, MichaelReprimand11/01/2005
Farris, ShawnReprimand05/19/2005
Anderson, JosephRemoval01/23/2004
Dobson, RichardReprimand04/17/2003
Harding, Raymond Jr.Removal Rendered Moot03/25/2003
Young, DavidReprimand11/07/2000
Bylsma, SamuelReprimand10/20/2000
Glasmann, MichaelCensure07/06/2000
Young, DavidReprimand08/27/1999
Alldredge, DeeReprimand06/22/1999
Dimick, JosephCensure01/23/1999
Chavez, PatriciaCensure01/13/1999
Payne, DavidCensure10/05/1998
Acomb, PeggyReprimand05/04/1998
Herring, WilliamReprimand11/17/1997
McCully, SharonReprimand07/08/1997
Shumate, JamesReprimand06/01/1997
Lema, MarlynnReprimand03/24/1997